So, it looks it was actually two lunches.
I wrote a post that started out talking about Table of Malcontents and ended up, several paragraphs later, talking about fair use and the history of copyright. It might be a good post, but I don't want to go off without doing the research necessary to minimize the talking out of my ass. So let's make this shorter.
Table of Malcontents, at least as I originally envisioned it, isn't just links to funny things on the Web. It's supposed to be about the people who make those funny things, and the community and culture that supports them. I've discovered, in the scant two days that I've been working on this thing, that that's not as easy as it sounds.
The reason for this is that, on the Web, art is increasingly becoming unmoored from its origins. I came across a couple videos on YouTube and Google Video that I enjoyed. Who made them? Are they clips from a television show or something a couple guys put together using a digital camera? Where can I find more by the people who made it?
I think of it as the Commons of Indifference. While some people are working on building a Creative Commons -- or a number of different Creative Commons -- within a fairly strict interpretation of copyright, others are taking the attitude that they'll put something up, and as long as nobody complains, it stays up. There are lots of cease and desist orders flying around, but for every reposting, repurposing, or parody that gets the C&D treatment, literally hundreds stay up with no comment from the ostensible owners.
Now, there's lots to say about this from a copyright point of view, and that's the part I'm avoiding for now. My keyboard-thumping on either side of the issue isn't going to change the way things currently work. On a personal level, though, it makes my job hard, and it makes me wonder if I'm working from an outdated paradigm. Is there any point in talking about indie versus corporate if it's all going to end up on Google Video? Should I care whether a joke on You're the Man Now Dog was actually made up by the poster or if it's a gag by a professional comedian with "Tarzan Boy" added on top of it?
That's just the stub of my thoughts, but I'm going to post it. I'm also enabling comments. I figure if my other blog and my column are up for commenting, why not just go with it?